A CalMatters investigation that revealed some California community college instructors are teaching more than a dozen online courses simultaneously — with a handful earning well over $340,000 a year — has prompted the state’s community college chancellor to launch a review of whether those classes meet basic quality standards required to keep federal and state financial aid flowing to students.
The inquiry comes after CalMatters reported last week on the sprawling workloads carried by some part-time faculty members across California’s community colleges, California State University and University of California systems. In several cases, instructors were found teaching simultaneously at multiple institutions, raising questions about how much individual attention students were actually receiving.
Community Colleges Chancellor Sonya Christian addressed the findings in a Nov. 13 email to campus leaders statewide, acknowledging that while teaching at more than one college isn’t inherently a problem, some of what the report uncovered demands closer examination. “We should not characterize faculty as doing something inappropriate simply because they teach at more than one college,” she wrote. “At the same time, some of the practices described in the article are deeply troubling and warrant further scrutiny.”
Christian said her office will now look into whether colleges are meeting state, federal and accreditation rules that require online instructors to maintain regular, substantive contact with students — through activities like leading discussions or responding promptly to questions. Falling short of those standards could jeopardize a college’s eligibility for federal financial aid programs that students depend on.
Mac Powell, who leads the organization responsible for accrediting California’s community colleges, said he has already contacted every school named in the CalMatters report to ask about compliance. “The issue of who teaches how much and when — that’s not what we’re most interested in,” Powell said. “We’re interested in the education that students get.”
The report’s top earner, ethnic studies instructor Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal, brought in nearly $800,000 in 2024 while teaching across nine community college districts, Cal State Sacramento and UC Berkeley, according to a CalMatters analysis of public payroll data, course catalogs and hiring records. This fall, she is again teaching roughly 30 classes serving about 1,100 students.
Some educators and administrators argue it’s simply not possible to deliver meaningful instruction under such a heavy load. Others caution that teaching many classes, or holding several jobs, doesn’t by itself prove a professor is shortchanging students.
A system shaped by economic necessity
Part-time, or adjunct, faculty members are a well-known fixture of California higher education, frequently stitching together several jobs to make ends meet. State law limits adjuncts in the community college system to roughly three classes per district each term, and they typically earn less than full-time faculty while receiving fewer benefits, if any.
Christian said she understands the pressures adjunct instructors face from personal experience. “When I first graduated, I taught at three California community colleges,” she wrote. “I didn’t own a car, so I rode the RTD bus from campus to campus to teach in person, piecing together assignments and barely making rent. I remember those days well. I understand firsthand why adjunct faculty teach at multiple institutions. For many, it is an economic necessity.”
Part-time instructors outnumber full-time faculty at every community college district in the state — in some cases by more than 5 to 1 — though the exact statewide total remains unclear because instructors working at multiple campuses are often counted more than once in official data.
Christian acknowledged in her email that there is currently no reliable system for tracking faculty who split their time across multiple colleges or across the community college, CSU and UC systems. Her office is now examining how districts monitor outside employment and what instructors are required to disclose. “The objective is to determine whether additional guidance, improved data sharing, or a common approach would strengthen institutional oversight,” she wrote.
To identify instructors teaching at multiple institutions, CalMatters relied on payroll data compiled by Transparent California, a nonprofit that advocates for government transparency. Reporters focused on professors who taught at five or more community college districts, CSU campuses or UC campuses in 2024, the most recent year with available data.
Among the 72 instructors identified, median pay came in around $190,000, though a handful earned far more. Ten professors topped $343,000 — roughly equal to the median salary of a community college president or chancellor that year. Most of the highest earners combined a full-time position with multiple part-time teaching jobs elsewhere. Ninh Villarreal currently holds at least two full-time tenured community college posts in addition to various adjunct assignments.
Christian emphasized that these 72 instructors represent a tiny fraction of the tens of thousands of faculty members working across California’s public higher education systems, with the highest earners making up an even smaller slice.
Scrutiny over student contact in online classes
Because state and federal governments distribute billions of dollars annually in financial aid, they impose rules on which courses and institutions qualify — and online classes have faced growing scrutiny in recent years. Both accrediting bodies and lawmakers generally agree that online instructors must maintain regular engagement with their students. Research has shown that students tend to perform better academically when they have meaningful contact with their professors.
Many online courses are asynchronous, meaning lectures are prerecorded for students to watch on their own schedule, and quizzes or exams are frequently graded automatically. Christian noted that such tools can have real value in online teaching, but they cannot substitute entirely for instructor engagement. “Low-quality instruction is unacceptable, and we will not tolerate practices that compromise the education our students deserve,” she said.
Following the initial CalMatters report, several online instructors who teach at fewer than five institutions spoke up to describe how they maintain contact with students despite using prerecorded materials.
William Mead, a full-time lecturer in design and web development at UC Davis who also teaches part-time at two community college districts, said his prerecorded lectures require extensive preparation precisely so he can devote more time to students during the term. “That front-loaded work is what frees me, during the semester, to focus on what matters most: individual feedback on student work and time with students,” he wrote in an email. He holds a weekly office hour along with three additional appointment blocks each week — one in the morning, one in the afternoon and one in the evening — so students with jobs or other obligations can meet with him over Zoom.
Jonathan Horn, who teaches a single asynchronous journalism course at San Diego Mesa College, said he provides detailed written feedback on student assignments — sometimes so much that he wonders if it’s excessive. He said that level of personalized attention simply wouldn’t be possible if he were juggling 30 or 50 sections at once.
Original source: CalMatters




