The California Department of Insurance broke its silence this past week on a lawsuit filed by a former administrative law judge accusing Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara and others of improperly approving rate increases — and in doing so, appears to have inadvertently confirmed that a second, currently sitting judge also filed misconduct complaints against department attorneys.
As CalMatters first reported, Administrative Law Judge Kristin Rosi sued Lara and his former special advisor, Lucy Wang, in late September. Rosi alleges she was fired in retaliation after ruling in 2024 that the two had improperly approved insurance companies’ requests to raise premiums on policyholders.
Under Proposition 103, the 1988 ballot measure that governs insurance regulation in California, the Department of Insurance must hold public hearings when an insurer seeks a rate hike of 7 percent or more and a member of the public formally objects through the state’s intervention process.
According to the lawsuit, filed in Alameda County Superior Court, Rosi’s rulings found that department officials had skipped required hearings, relied on regulations that were never properly authorized, and sidestepped rules meant to keep settlement agreements transparent. Rosi claims that after she issued those rulings, Lara, Wang and unnamed department staffers tried to pressure her into changing her findings or issuing rulings a certain way — allegations detailed in her court filing.
“While our policy is not to comment on pending litigation, the severity of these blatantly false accusations and glaring inaccuracies demand a response,” department spokesperson Gabriel Sanchez said in an email to CalMatters. Sanchez said the department intends to mount a vigorous defense, maintaining that “Commissioner Lara and department staff acted appropriately, legally, and within the decades-old framework of Proposition 103 at all times, to protect consumers and ensure accountability in their operations.”
Last year, Rosi filed complaints with the State Bar against Wang and three other department attorneys. Those complaints, which are not public but were obtained by CalMatters, lay out alleged repeated violations of state law — including closed-door meetings that Rosi contends should have included all parties to rate hearings, such as insurance companies and the consumer advocates known as intervenors.
Sanchez said Rosi “misunderstood” how Proposition 103 procedures work and noted that the State Bar ultimately closed its investigation without finding wrongdoing. He provided CalMatters with a July 14 letter from a State Bar investigator confirming the matter was closed. That letter stated that the State Bar had “concluded the investigation of the allegations of professional misconduct” brought by “the Honorable Kristin L. Rosi and the Honorable Fredric J. Seligman.”
The mention of Seligman appears to be the first public indication that another sitting administrative law judge also lodged complaints with the State Bar. Seligman is currently the only person listed as an administrative law judge on the department’s website. His office did not immediately respond to a request for comment from CalMatters.
Wendy Musell, Rosi’s attorney, said her client has appealed the State Bar’s decision to close the complaints. “My understanding is that the State Bar still has jurisdiction and that the matter remains under appeal,” she said.
Rosi had served as an administrative law judge in the department’s Administrative Hearing Bureau since 2007 and was elevated to presiding judge in 2016. The department placed her on leave in January 2025, posted her position as vacant that July, and confirmed her termination in November 2025, according to her lawsuit.
Because Rosi sued Lara, Wang and other unnamed staffers in their capacity as state officials, the California Department of Justice is representing them in the case.
Lara’s second term as insurance commissioner is set to end in January. Wang left the department in late 2025 and has since taken a position with a law firm that represents the insurance industry.
Original source: CalMatters




