California Mandated Dental Checkups for Students, Then Failed to Track Compliance

Date:

California’s two-decade-old effort to catch dental problems in young schoolchildren is falling short of its goals, according to a scathing new state audit that found unreliable data, little oversight and shrinking funding threaten the program’s future.

The Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment, established in 2006, requires families to show proof that their child has seen a dentist before starting transitional kindergarten, kindergarten or first grade in a California public school. The idea was straightforward: catch cavities and other dental issues early, connect families with care, and flag barriers keeping kids from getting treatment.

But a report released Nov. 5 by California State Auditor Grant Parks found the program has been plagued by poor recordkeeping, confusing reporting requirements and a near-total absence of state oversight. The audit examined six school districts — Los Angeles Unified, Merced City, Milpitas Unified, Oakland Unified, San Luis Coastal Unified and Woodland Joint Unified — along with the California Department of Public Health.

Tooth decay remains the most common chronic childhood disease in the country, even though it is largely preventable. A 2021 state report found that roughly 61% of California third graders had experienced tooth decay during the 2018-19 school year, and many experts say the problem has only worsened since the pandemic. Left untreated, dental pain can keep kids out of class entirely — a 2025 survey from the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research found nearly 7% of school-age children missed school because of dental issues.

Despite those stakes, the audit found that no single state agency has been assigned to oversee the kindergarten dental program. Neither the California Department of Education nor the Department of Public Health monitors how well it’s being carried out. The health department, which is tasked with improving statewide oral health outcomes, has not verified the accuracy of data submitted by districts and isn’t using that information to track whether children’s dental health is actually improving.

The state hasn’t published a public analysis of program data in years — the most recent figures available online are from the 2020-21 school year, posted not by a state agency but by the California Dental Association.

Department of Public Health spokesperson Kristine Tuzon said the agency’s hands are tied by state law, which she said does not grant the department authority to enforce data-reporting requirements or notify county education offices when districts fail to submit information.

Reporting errors were widespread among the districts reviewed. Auditors found that five of the six submitted numbers to the state that differed significantly from their own local records. Los Angeles Unified, the state’s largest district, mistakenly counted all first-graders as subject to the assessment requirement during the 2024-25 school year, rather than limiting the count to students entering the district for the first time. The district also overstated how many students had actually turned in proof of a dental visit.

“The magnitude of the reporting errors by Los Angeles Unified School District alone skews any statewide analysis of the collective data,” Parks wrote in the report.

Esther Yepez, associate director of wellness programs and oral health at The Los Angeles Trust for Children’s Health, said her organization ran dental screenings at LAUSD campuses for five years and routinely ran into a disconnect between the screenings her team completed and what ended up logged in district records. Paperwork would be left with school staff, she said, but often never made it into the district’s tracking system — and it wasn’t always clear who on campus was responsible for inputting the data.

“It was frustrating,” Yepez said, “because we had information that the screenings had happened, but the schools didn’t have that data.”

LAUSD did not respond to questions about the accuracy of its reporting. In a written response included in the audit, Joel Cisneros, the district’s executive director of student mental health and wellness services, said LAUSD intends to train school staff on proper data entry and establish a consistent process for tracking returned forms and waivers.

Pediatric dental experts say the stakes of getting this right are high. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentists recommends children see a dentist by their first birthday, but Dr. Francisco Ramos-Gomez, chair of pediatric dentistry at the UCLA School of Dentistry and director of the UCLA Center for Children’s Oral Health, said many low-income families face steep obstacles — limited transportation, language barriers and a shortage of providers willing to treat children on public insurance.

“If we start seeing these children by age 3 or 4,” he said, “they already come with rotten teeth, abscesses and huge pain.”

State law allows parents to waive the assessment requirement if they face financial hardship, can’t access a dental provider, or simply decline to consent. But auditors found that none of the six districts reviewed gave families all the information they were legally required to receive about the requirement. None had a formal system for following up with families who never returned assessment forms or who submitted waivers citing barriers to care.

In their responses to the audit, Milpitas and Oakland Unified said they would adopt the recommended fixes, while LAUSD and San Luis Coastal Unified outlined partial action plans. Merced City and Woodland Joint did not respond to the audit’s findings.

Compounding the problem is a funding squeeze. The kindergarten program relies in part on Proposition 56 tobacco tax revenue, which the state distributes to county health departments to support oral health work. But as smoking rates decline, so does that revenue stream — and starting next year, the state will no longer require counties receiving those funds to support the kindergarten assessment program specifically.

Tuzon said the health department is reviewing options to sustain compliance efforts amid the funding decline.

Eileen Espejo, senior managing director for health at the advocacy group Children Now, said the data problems shouldn’t overshadow a more pressing question facing lawmakers: how to keep the program funded at all.

“Local health programs are going to have less capacity to do some of the work,” she said. “There needs to be that conversation of, ‘Where is the money coming from to help increase compliance?'”

Original source: CalMatters

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Low-Quality Online Courses Could Put Students’ Financial Aid at Risk

A CalMatters investigation that revealed some California community college...

California Democrats Expand Statehouse Supermajority as GOP Grapples With Internal Divisions

California Republicans emerged from this month’s election with their...

Becerra Confronts $2 Billion Budget Gap Amid Fears of AI Investment Slowdown

California’s finances are once again riding a wave of...