Prosecutors from 30 California counties filed suit Monday asking the state Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s sweeping move to commute the sentences of condemned prisoners, setting up a high-stakes legal fight over the governor’s clemency powers just weeks before he leaves office.
The petition, filed directly with the state’s highest court, contends Newsom overstepped his authority by proposing to commute the sentences of 548 death row inmates without first giving crime victims and their families a chance to weigh in, as state law requires in clemency cases.
“Only this court can stop the governor’s disregard of the law — his abuse of power,” the district attorneys wrote in their filing.
The prosecutors argue that Newsom’s commutation authority differs sharply from the broad, largely unchecked pardon power held by a U.S. president. Under California law, they say, a governor considering a commutation must notify both the district attorney who prosecuted the case and the victims or surviving family members, giving them an opportunity to be heard before any decision is finalized.
Newsom appears to have anticipated the legal challenge. In a detailed explanatory statement issued alongside his clemency announcement, he argued that the notification requirements cited by prosecutors apply only when an inmate formally petitions for clemency — not when a governor acts on his own initiative, as he did in proposing this mass commutation. Because none of the condemned prisoners had filed individual applications, Newsom maintains, the statutory notice provisions simply don’t apply to this case.
He also noted that his office intends to work with county district attorneys to notify victims’ families after submitting the commutation proposals to the Supreme Court for review.
The state’s high court will ultimately have jurisdiction over roughly 400 of the commutations, since California law mandates judicial review for any clemency grant involving an inmate convicted of multiple felonies. It remains unclear how or when the court will conduct that review, and a spokesperson for the court has not detailed a timeline.
Newsom has sought to wind down capital punishment in California throughout his tenure, imposing a moratorium on executions in 2019 and later ordering the removal of San Quentin State Prison’s execution chamber. Incoming Gov. Xavier Becerra, who takes office next month, has pledged to keep the moratorium in place.
The outcome of the prosecutors’ lawsuit could determine whether Newsom’s final major act on criminal justice stands — or whether it becomes entangled in legal challenges that outlast his administration.
Original source: CalMatters




