Texas Isn’t Turning Blue Because of Californians, Data Shows

Date:

Did California transplants tip Texas toward Democrats in this month’s elections? A closer look at the numbers suggests the answer is no — at least when it comes to the state’s blockbuster U.S. Senate race.

The question has circulated widely since Texas Democrat James Talarico defeated Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton, a close ally of President Donald Trump, by nearly 1.2 million votes. With Talarico’s win part of a broader Democratic surge across Texas, some have speculated that an influx of California expatriates helped fuel the shift. But an analysis of migration and voter data tells a different story.

Internal Revenue Service migration records show more than 364,000 Californians relocated to Texas between 2018 and 2023. Drawing on recent research examining interstate voter rolls, analysts estimate that fewer than one-third of those voting-age transplants were registered Democrats before leaving California. Even under the most generous assumptions — that every single one of those former Californians was registered to vote in Texas, turned out at the polls and backed Talarico — they would account for roughly 103,000 votes, or only about 10% of his margin of victory.

Other research backs up the idea that California’s outmigration to Texas doesn’t skew heavily liberal. A 2023 Stanford University study found that about half of Californians who moved to Texas or Arizona in recent years identified as conservative. Separately, the Public Policy Institute of California has found that conservative Californians are more likely than liberals to relocate to right-leaning states.

A county-by-county review reinforces the point. Every Texas county shifted anywhere from 7 to 70 percentage points toward Talarico compared with the 2024 presidential race, when Trump won the state comfortably. Yet the five counties with the largest swings toward Democrats had fewer than one California transplant household per 1,000 households — meaning Talarico would have won those counties even without a single California transplant casting a ballot.

Meanwhile, counties with the highest concentrations of California transplants shifted toward Talarico at roughly the same rate as the state overall, suggesting those newcomers didn’t meaningfully alter the political trajectory.

“There is not an unusual or disproportionately Democratic skew” among people who’ve moved to Texas, said David Crockett, a political science professor at Trinity University in San Antonio.

In other words, Texas’s political transformation appears to be happening largely among Texans themselves.

MIXED SIGNALS ON TAXES

California voters sent conflicting messages on taxation this election cycle, according to a review by CalMatters reporters.

The Associated Press confirmed Friday that voters approved Proposition 42, which prohibits new wealth taxes on personal property, business holdings and financial investments. Combined with the defeat of Proposition 40, a proposed tax targeting billionaires, the results suggest voters remain protective of wealth accumulated by the state’s richest residents.

But that doesn’t mean Californians have soured on taxation altogether. Voters also rejected Proposition 43, which would have made it harder for local governments to raise taxes for public services, and approved Proposition 3, cementing a tax on high earners that funds public schools.

Experts say the split outcome reflects a consistent pattern: Californians are willing to tax the wealthy or themselves when they trust the money will go toward specific, visible public benefits.

“Voters are willing to open up their wallet if they believe it’s for a good cause … and that it’s actually going to that place,” said Brandon Castillo, a California ballot measure strategist.

DEATH PENALTY FIGHT CONTINUES DESPITE COMMUTATIONS

Local prosecutors across California say they intend to keep pursuing capital punishment even after Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision last week to commute the sentences of more than 500 death row inmates, CalMatters justice reporter Jeanne Kuang reports.

Nearly 400 of those commutations still require sign-off from the California Supreme Court. But prosecutors say the state will likely continue sending convicted murderers to death row regardless of the high court’s decision.

San Bernardino County District Attorney Jason Anderson is among several prosecutors vowing to continue seeking death sentences in appropriate cases. While he said he respects differing views on capital punishment, Anderson argued Newsom should have reviewed each case individually rather than issuing a sweeping commutation.

“You have a law on the books that’s essentially been overridden by one person,” Anderson said.

Anderson has also moved to unseal the criminal records of several San Bernardino County inmates who received commutations, arguing the public deserves to know the details of their crimes and what he calls their “recidivist nature.” The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, which opposes Newsom’s action, has filed similar requests in other cases.

TELL PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS WHAT MATTERS TO YOU

CalMatters has teamed up with Your Local Epidemiologist to gather input from Californians on pressing public health concerns, with the goal of putting real community questions in front of officials and journalists.

Each Monday, a new survey focuses on a different health topic and takes just a couple of minutes to complete. This week’s survey examines the health effects of holiday gatherings and the broader issue of social isolation. Residents interested in weighing in can find the survey through CalMatters’ website.

Original source: CalMatters

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

California Taxpayers Are Footing the Bill for Oil Companies’ Risky Carbon Capture Gamble

California is pouring public money into an unproven climate...

Soboba Fire Station Microgrid Project completion celebrated

The Soboba Band of Luiseño Indians celebrated the completion...

Californians Say Yes to Taxing the Wealthy — Just Not Always

California voters sent a confusing message about taxes this...

State Insurance Department’s Accidental Disclosure Reveals Another Judge’s Misconduct Complaint

The California Department of Insurance broke its silence Friday...