California is pouring public money into an unproven climate fix that mainly serves the oil industry’s bottom line, and residents deserve to know what’s at stake.
The United Nations recently confirmed what scientists have long feared: the world has missed its window to hold global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. In response, policymakers are increasingly betting on carbon capture and storage, a technology that pulls carbon dioxide from industrial smokestacks and buries it underground. The idea sounds promising. The results so far do not.
A ProPublica investigation published in June found that today’s carbon capture facilities collectively bury less CO2 in a year than a single large power plant emits during that same period. Not a single project has come close to the industry’s touted capture rates of up to 95 percent. Despite that track record, oil companies have successfully lobbied Sacramento to embrace carbon capture in a big way, backed by generous federal tax credits and state incentives, even before regulators have finished writing the rules that are supposed to govern how the carbon is stored.
This matters for communities across California, including here in the Inland Empire, where pipeline infrastructure and oil industry influence are already part of daily life. Last year, state lawmakers lifted a partial moratorium on building pipelines that would carry pressurized CO2 to underground storage sites. Troublingly, the law doesn’t require an odorant be added to the gas to warn residents of leaks, nor does it establish meaningful buffer zones between pipelines and nearby neighborhoods.
That omission is not a small technicality. Carbon dioxide, when released in a concentrated cloud, can displace oxygen near the ground and cause people to suffocate. It’s not theoretical. In 2020, a CO2 pipeline ruptured near Satartia, Mississippi, sending 45 people to the hospital and forcing roughly 200 residents to evacuate. Survivors described gasping for air, losing consciousness, and foaming at the mouth.
Despite that cautionary tale, companies in California are moving ahead with similar projects. In the Bay Area, a company called Montezuma Carbon wants to build a 40-mile pipeline to funnel CO2 from regional power plants and utilities, then inject it nearly two miles beneath the Montezuma Wetlands, a sensitive habitat for local wildlife. Residents near the proposed project have already begun organizing in opposition.
Closer to the Central Valley, about 20 miles west of Bakersfield, California Resources Corp. — the state’s largest oil producer — began injecting compressed carbon dioxide into a depleted oil reservoir this past May. The gas comes from the company’s cryogenic processing plant. Critics point out that the underground geology in these oil fields is riddled with decades-old wells, raising real concerns about whether the injected CO2 could migrate upward and escape.
California Resources itself has acknowledged that these ventures only pencil out because of government support. In its own 2025 financial filings, the company stated plainly that its carbon capture projects “depend on financial and tax incentives established under federal and state laws, regulations and governmental programs to be economically viable.” Without that public subsidy, the economics simply don’t work.
It’s worth asking why an oil company is so invested in this technology to begin with. An analysis by the FracTracker Alliance found that most of California Resources’ roughly 40,000 wells produce little to no oil today. Meanwhile, the U.S. Energy Information Administration estimates the state has about 1.2 billion barrels of proven oil reserves remaining, enough to last roughly 14 years at 2025 production levels. Tapping new reserves is costly and tangled in regulatory requirements. Carbon capture, subsidized by taxpayers, offers the industry a lucrative fallback.
But that fallback comes at a cost to everyone else. A 2025 study led by Stanford researchers found that every dollar spent on carbon capture and storage, rather than on wind, solar, and other renewable energy sources, actually increases overall carbon emissions, air pollution, energy costs, and total costs to society once pipeline infrastructure and other factors are considered.
Given the risks and the weak track record, California should reconsider its support for carbon capture storage and instead require oil companies like California Resources to pay to properly plug their aging wells and clean up the pollution they’ve already caused. Redirecting public dollars away from this costly experiment and toward renewable energy, efficiency programs, and electrification would do far more to address the climate crisis — and keep Southern California communities safer in the process.
Original source: CalMatters




