The U.S. Supreme Court has refused to take up the Trump administration’s appeal in a case that forced federal agencies to restore hundreds of millions of dollars in research grants to University of California scientists, letting stand lower court rulings that found the grant cancellations likely violated researchers’ free speech rights.
The high court announced its decision without comment, a common practice when justices decline to hear a case. No dissent was noted.
At issue was the administration’s move to strip UC researchers of roughly $900 million in federal funding between January and July of last year, with UCLA alone losing nearly $600 million. The Trump administration had argued that agencies were within their rights to pull grants that conflicted with executive orders targeting diversity, equity and inclusion programs and climate change research.
Attorneys representing the UC scientists countered that the cancellations amounted to a direct assault on academic freedom. Losing funding, staff and graduate students quickly turns into something more troubling, they argued in court filings — researchers silenced, unable to publish or contribute to public discourse. That, they said, is exactly the kind of harm the First Amendment is meant to prevent.
The case, Thakur v. Trump, touched a wide swath of academic disciplines, from U.S. history to disease research to basic biology. A federal judge had already ordered most of the canceled grants restored, and the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals backed that decision, agreeing that the funding cuts likely crossed a constitutional line.
CalMatters previously reported that federal agencies used keyword searches — flagging terms like “diversity” or “climate change” in grant applications — to identify funding for termination. The Department of Energy, according to the reporting, specifically targeted states that backed Kamala Harris over Trump in the 2024 election.
Some of the funding fights had nothing to do with social policy at all. Attorneys for the researchers pointed out that the National Science Foundation canceled studies simply because they used the word “diversity” in a purely scientific sense — research with titles like “Effects of Leaf Diversity on Aquatic Insect Colonizer Diversity” lost funding despite having no connection to DEI initiatives.
In another case highlighted by CalMatters, the National Institutes of Health pulled a $36 million dementia research grant led by a UC Davis professor last April, citing its focus on diversity — even though that same focus had been required under grant guidelines established during Trump’s first term. The agency quietly restored the funding shortly after CalMatters reported on the cancellation.
Claudia Polsky, an attorney representing the UC researchers, said Tuesday’s Supreme Court decision will likely influence similar lawsuits playing out in courts around the country, where other researchers are making the same First Amendment argument after having their grants pulled. While other courts aren’t legally bound by the 9th Circuit’s ruling, Polsky said she expects judges to find it persuasive, especially now that the Supreme Court declined to intervene.
She added that the outcome could directly benefit a group of Cal State professors who sued the administration last month over canceled National Science Foundation grants. Polsky said she doubts the administration will try again to bring the case before the Supreme Court, given the lack of any noted dissent.
The legal team representing the UC researchers is scheduled to appear in a lower court Tuesday to argue that the administration’s termination of separate Department of Energy grants was also unlawful. That matter is technically a separate case from the one the Supreme Court declined to review.
At the heart of the broader legal fight is a fundamental question: once the federal government commits to funding a research project, can a new administration simply walk away from that commitment because it disagrees with the project’s goals? Attorneys for the researchers argue that once a grant is awarded, scientists should be allowed to see the work through — regardless of which administration originally approved it or how a successor views its value.
Justice Department lawyers took the opposite position, arguing that canceling already-approved funding doesn’t violate anyone’s constitutional rights, since researchers remain free to pursue private funding elsewhere. Federal agencies had already acknowledged in signed statements this summer that the UC researchers had broken no rules and had complied fully with the terms of their grants. Still, the administration argued that compliance didn’t matter if the research no longer aligned with the president’s priorities.
Attorneys for the researchers warned that accepting the administration’s reasoning would destabilize federally funded science and humanities work nationwide, making any multiyear research project vulnerable to cancellation the moment a new president takes office. U.S. District Judge Rita F. Lin, who initially ordered the grants restored, agreed, writing that researchers facing sudden funding losses would be forced into layoffs, career setbacks and a scramble for alternative funding sources with little hope of success.
The Department of Justice was representing several federal agencies in the case, including the Department of Defense, the Department of Transportation, the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation. A related dispute involving the Environmental Protection Agency was resolved through a settlement earlier this year.
Lawyers for the researchers also pushed back on the administration’s broader legal theory, arguing that no federal court has ever endorsed the idea that a president can cancel merit-based research grants simply because of how the underlying viewpoint is perceived. They noted that Congress itself built language into the laws governing agencies like the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities encouraging support for women, people of color, people with disabilities and historically underrepresented scholars and institutions — provisions, they argued, the administration is now effectively disregarding.
Original source: CalMatters




