The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to take up a case that could have cleared the way for the Trump administration to strip hundreds of millions of dollars in research funding from University of California scientists and scholars, handing a significant win to UC researchers and setting a precedent that legal experts say will ripple through similar disputes nationwide.
The high court issued its decision Monday without comment, a common practice when justices reject a case. The move leaves in place a lower court ruling that found the administration likely violated researchers’ First Amendment rights when it canceled their federal grants.
The case, known as Thakur v. Trump, centered on whether the White House could cancel previously approved research grants because the underlying projects touched on topics the administration opposed, including diversity-related research and studies on the effects of climate change. The Trump administration argued it had the authority to cancel the funding because the projects conflicted with executive orders targeting so-called diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives.
Attorneys representing the UC researchers countered that the administration’s approach threatened both the integrity of scientific research and scholars’ constitutional rights. In court filings, they warned that the financial damage — lost funding, laid-off staff, displaced graduate students and postdoctoral researchers — would soon give way to a deeper harm: the silencing of academic work and its ability to shape public discourse.
Between January and July of last year, the White House canceled more than $900 million in grants to UC researchers, including nearly $600 million at UCLA alone. Almost all of that funding was later restored after a federal district judge ordered several agencies to reinstate the grants. When the government appealed, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld those rulings, finding that the administration had likely trampled on researchers’ free speech protections.
As CalMatters has previously reported, federal agencies used keyword searches — flagging terms such as “diversity” or “climate change” in grant applications — to identify projects for defunding. The Department of Energy, meanwhile, targeted cuts specifically toward states that voted for Kamala Harris rather than Donald Trump in the 2024 election.
Some of the casualties were notably unrelated to any diversity initiative. According to attorneys for the researchers, the National Science Foundation flagged grants simply because the word “diversity” appeared in a scientific context — including studies with titles such as “Effects of Leaf Diversity on Aquatic Insect Colonizer Diversity” and “Unveiling the Vast Diversity Within the Legume-Rhizobium Mutualism.”
Even the National Institutes of Health, which requires studies to include diverse populations of research subjects, was swept up in the cuts. In April of last year, the agency canceled a $36 million dementia research grant led by a UC Davis professor, citing its focus on diversity — only to reverse course and restore the funding shortly after CalMatters reported on the decision.
Claudia Polsky, an attorney representing the UC researchers, said Monday’s Supreme Court decision strengthens the position of researchers across the country who are fighting similar grant cancellations. Attorneys in other cases can now point to both the Ninth Circuit’s ruling in favor of UC researchers and the Supreme Court’s refusal to disturb it.
While lower courts are not technically bound by the decision, Polsky said she expects it to carry significant weight. She also said she doubts the administration will attempt another appeal, given that no justices dissented from Monday’s order.
The ruling could also bolster a separate lawsuit filed last month by Cal State faculty challenging the cancellation of their own National Science Foundation grants, Polsky said.
Attorneys for the UC researchers are scheduled to appear in a lower court Tuesday to argue that the Department of Energy’s cancellation of related grants was similarly unlawful — a case that, while connected in spirit, is technically separate from the Supreme Court’s decision.
At the heart of the broader legal fight is a fundamental question: once a federal grant has been awarded, can a new administration simply cancel it because officials disagree with the research’s focus?
Attorneys for the researchers argue that once funding is awarded — regardless of which administration approved it — scholars should be allowed to complete their work, even if a subsequent administration views the research as an unwise use of taxpayer dollars. The Justice Department, however, maintained that the federal government retains the authority to rescind previously approved grants and that doing so does not violate the First Amendment, since researchers remain free to seek private funding instead.
According to sworn statements filed by federal agencies this summer, UC researchers broke no rules set by Congress and fully complied with federal guidelines on how grant money should be used. Still, the administration canceled the funding anyway, arguing the research no longer aligned with the president’s priorities.
Attorneys for the researchers warned that if the administration’s legal reasoning were upheld, it would destabilize federally funded research across the sciences and humanities, since any multiyear project extending into a new presidential term could be abruptly defunded based on shifting political priorities.
U.S. District Judge Rita F. Lin, an appointee of President Biden, agreed with that assessment when she first ordered agencies to restore the canceled grants. She wrote that researchers faced unexpected funding gaps, the likelihood of staff layoffs, and lasting damage to their careers and reputations if their projects could not be completed — along with the burden of pursuing alternative funding sources with little chance of success.
The Justice Department represented several federal agencies in the case, including the Department of Defense, the Department of Transportation, the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation. A similar dispute involving the Environmental Protection Agency was resolved through a settlement earlier this year.
Attorneys for the researchers also argued that the administration ignored procedures Congress established for terminating grants. They pointed to federal statutes that direct agencies such as the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities to support research involving women, people of color and individuals with disabilities — and to give particular consideration to scholars and institutions that have historically been underrepresented in federally funded research.
Original source: CalMatters




