District attorneys from 30 California counties have filed suit asking the state Supreme Court to block Governor Gavin Newsom’s bid to commute the sentences of hundreds of death row inmates, arguing the governor sidestepped victims’ legal right to be heard before such decisions are made.
The petition, filed Monday with the California Supreme Court, accuses Newsom of acting outside the bounds of his authority by moving to commute the sentences of 548 condemned prisoners without first giving crime victims or their families a chance to weigh in, as state law requires.
“Only this court can stop the governor’s disregard for the law, his abuse of power,” the prosecutors wrote in their filing.
The district attorneys drew a sharp line between a governor’s commutation powers and a president’s pardon authority. While presidential pardons face virtually no restrictions outside of impeachment proceedings, California law requires governors to notify the district attorney in the county where a crime occurred, along with victims or their relatives, before granting clemency to someone sentenced to death.
Anticipating that very argument, Newsom’s office released an explanatory statement outlining why he believed notification wasn’t legally required in this case. Central to his reasoning: none of the prisoners involved had actually petitioned for a commutation. Because he initiated the mass clemency action on his own, Newsom contends the usual notification rules don’t apply.
The specific penal code provision cited by the district attorneys, Newsom wrote, “does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative to grant clemency absent a request.” He noted that once the commutation petitions are formally submitted to the state’s high court, his administration would notify district attorneys in the relevant counties and ask for their assistance in reaching victims and their families.
The California Supreme Court is required by law to weigh in on nearly 400 of the proposed commutations, since those cases involve prisoners convicted of multiple violent felonies. Court officials have not yet said how or when that review process will unfold.
Newsom first halted executions in California back in 2019, issuing a moratorium and later ordering the state to dismantle the execution chamber at San Quentin State Prison. Governor-elect Xavier Becerra, who will succeed Newsom in office, has pledged to keep that moratorium in place once he is sworn in.
Original source: CalMatters




