Becerra Warns California Could Face $2 Billion Budget Shortfall if AI Bubble Bursts

Date:

California is riding high on an unexpected wave of tax revenue, fueled by a stock market that has surged on enthusiasm for artificial intelligence. But state fiscal analysts are warning that this windfall is no foundation on which to build long-term budget stability — and that the risks of a market correction are growing, not shrinking.

In its annual economic forecast released Wednesday, the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office cautioned that California’s deep structural budget problems remain unresolved, even as AI-driven stock gains pump billions of extra dollars into state coffers. If the market cools next year as expected, the state could still face a modest $2 billion shortfall by the end of the 2027-28 fiscal year. But if that cooling accelerates, the annual deficit could balloon to $15 billion by 2028-29, according to Legislative Analyst Gabe Petek.

Closing a gap that large, Petek said, would likely require eliminating nearly every expansion of state services approved since the 2019-20 fiscal year — including the extension of Medi-Cal coverage to immigrants without legal status — or imposing a new tax even steeper than the state’s current 10% to 12% levy on top earners, which voters just made permanent through Proposition 3.

And if the market doesn’t just cool but crashes outright, the fallout could be far worse: an annual deficit of $35 billion by 2028-29, a hole so deep that the state’s reserves wouldn’t be enough to fill it.

A Fifth Straight Year of Warning Signs

This marks the fifth consecutive year that California’s nonpartisan budget analysts have projected a deficit despite rising revenues — a pattern that underscores just how fragile the state’s finances remain.

The forecast offers an early look at the financial challenges awaiting Governor-elect Xavier Becerra, who will unveil his first state budget proposal in January alongside an updated economic outlook from the Department of Finance, which could diverge sharply from the LAO’s more cautious projections.

If the LAO’s warnings prove accurate, however, Becerra will inherit a far shakier financial picture than the one his predecessor promised. In June, Governor Gavin Newsom signed a budget he said would balance the state’s books for two consecutive years and cut future deficits in half. That plan leaned heavily on AI-fueled revenue growth to delay major cuts to health care services, particularly for undocumented immigrants. Those cuts are set to take effect next year unless Becerra identifies new funding to keep the programs intact.

Becerra has offered few specifics about his budget priorities so far, though he has signaled openness to new revenue sources, including a “fair share” tax targeting wealthy Californians and a controversial per-mile fee on drivers to help pay for road repairs. He has also said he intends to work to reverse recent cuts to health coverage for undocumented immigrants, though he has not detailed how.

In a statement Wednesday, Becerra spokesperson Jonathan Underland said the governor-elect is “working hard” on his January budget proposal and “remains committed to crafting a responsible and balanced budget that protects the services Californians rely on while focusing on reducing costs.”

A Call for Fiscal Discipline

Given the risk of a market downturn, the LAO urged the incoming administration to move quickly to “rebuild budgetary resilience” — through aggressive saving, paying down outstanding debts, and pursuing long-term cuts or new revenue streams rather than relying on temporary fixes.

Assembly Democratic leaders pointed to voters’ approval of Proposition 2 earlier this month as a step in the right direction. The measure raises the cap on the state’s rainy day fund from 10% to 20% of general tax revenue and requires California to set aside more money during economic booms — guidance lawmakers say will be essential moving forward.

Senate Democrats, meanwhile, say they intend to look for ways to offset recent federal cuts to Medi-Cal imposed under the Trump administration, which the LAO estimates have left roughly 2 million Californians without health coverage. Earlier this year, Senate Democrats floated a proposal to tax large corporations whose employees rely on Medi-Cal, using the revenue to help fund health care costs. Becerra, who has backed the concept, is required to present a formal plan by March.

Republicans Urge a Reality Check

Senate Republican Leader Roger Niello, vice chair of the Senate budget committee, called on the incoming administration to confront the state’s fiscal reality head-on.

“It’s only a matter of time before the stock market returns to more normal levels,” Niello said in a statement. “Balancing the state budget in a way that works in both good times and bad will help us avoid the consequences of having to make even more drastic changes to the everyday lives of Californians. Otherwise, when the market eventually corrects, the consequences of today’s budget problems will catch up with us.”

Since 2023, a red-hot economy driven largely by investor enthusiasm for artificial intelligence has generated substantial tax revenue for California, even as economists and legislative analysts repeatedly warned that the boom carried real risk.

According to Petek, Americans now hold 175% more stock than the historical average, and investors have doubled their borrowing over the past three years to buy into the market. “This borders on euphoria,” he said.

A Boom That Could Still Go Bust

That enthusiasm, analysts caution, doesn’t mean the warnings have been wrong — it may mean the opposite.

“It could be tempting to conclude that this means these signals are wrong this time. But we caution that the reverse could be true: the risk of a market reversal is even greater now,” the LAO report states. “The risk facing state revenues now is that this boom, like many in the past, ends abruptly in a bust.”

For now, analysts expect the AI-fueled boom to generate about $11 billion more in revenue than the Department of Finance projected back in June, assuming the market cools gradually rather than collapsing in 2027, Petek said.

But under the state constitution, nearly all of that new revenue — and then some — is already spoken for, earmarked for education funding and state reserves rather than available for other spending priorities.

Roughly $4 billion of the additional revenue must go toward K-12 schools and community colleges under Proposition 98, the 1988 ballot measure that guarantees a minimum funding level for education. Under Proposition 2, state leaders are also required to deposit another $9 billion into reserves this year — a mandate for more aggressive saving at a moment when the market remains especially volatile.

Meanwhile, the state is expected to spend about $600 million more than anticipated in June on programs like Medi-Cal, even as enrollment declines, largely due to rising costs for health coverage and social services, according to the LAO.

A Structural Problem That Won’t Go Away

The possibility of a market downturn only adds to the precariousness of California’s already volatile budget situation.

The state relies heavily on the wages and investment earnings of its wealthiest residents — income that rises and falls with the stock market. Over the years, state spending has consistently outpaced revenue as leaders expanded programs like Medi-Cal, even as the costs of running those programs climbed sharply.

To cope, state officials have repeatedly turned to short-term fixes: internal borrowing, dipping into reserves, and delaying new spending commitments rather than making painful cuts to social services.

None of those measures have restored real balance. As a result, the state now carries nearly $30 billion in debt, according to the LAO.

“This means that the underlying imbalance has persisted, and the level of ongoing services has not been adjusted downward to reflect this more limited capacity, suggesting that the expanded size of state government was unsustainable,” the office wrote in a report earlier this month.

Original source: CalMatters

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Does the Democratic Supermajority Serve California Voters?

California Republicans are facing their smallest legislative footprint in...

California Mandated Dental Checkups for Students, Then Failed to Track Compliance

California's two-decade-old effort to catch dental problems in young...

Low-Quality Online Courses Could Put Students’ Financial Aid at Risk

A CalMatters investigation that revealed some California community college...