As another El Niño winter bears down on California, a small Delta town that once stood at the forefront of a groundbreaking flood insurance experiment finds itself without the very safety net it helped pioneer.
Two years ago, the river community of Isleton became the first place in California to test a state-funded, community-based flood insurance program designed to pay out automatically once water levels crossed a certain threshold — no lengthy claims process required. State officials celebrated it as a bold new model for helping vulnerable communities cope with climate-driven disasters.
“We need to think creatively about how new insurance pilots like this Delta community project can be tested and scaled to help our most vulnerable communities,” California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara said when the program launched.
Today, that pilot sits dormant, undone not by a flawed concept but by the same financial strain and political turmoil that leave many California communities dangerously underinsured against flooding.
A town built on risk
Home to fewer than 800 residents, Isleton sits along the Sacramento River in one of the state’s highest-risk flood zones. Poverty rates there run roughly double the statewide average, and the levees protecting the town are aging and vulnerable. Those levees have failed before — most notably in 1972, when a summer flood submerged the city under eight feet of water and forced a mass evacuation that lasted months.
Longtime resident Pam Bulahan, who was 9 years old during that flood, still remembers being woken before sunrise and told to flee to higher ground. She recalls the stench of the floodwaters creeping through town — thick, foul, and frightening.
Despite that history, only about half of Isleton’s homes carry flood insurance, according to an analysis of FEMA data by hazard mitigation consultant Jeanine Foster. That’s better than the statewide average but still far below what experts recommend for a town so exposed to disaster.
A novel idea takes root
The push for a new kind of insurance in Isleton came from Kathleen Schaefer, a UC Davis graduate student who spent nearly a decade working for FEMA before returning to academia. Her pilot program used what’s known as parametric insurance — coverage that pays a predetermined amount when a disaster hits a certain severity threshold, such as a specific water level, rather than reimbursing actual property damage.
Unlike traditional insurance, parametric coverage can fund costs that standard policies typically ignore, including evacuation expenses, lost business revenue, and interruptions to local services. Lara had praised that flexibility, noting payouts could arrive quickly and without red tape.
To administer the plan, Schaefer helped create the Delta Region Geologic Hazard Abatement District, a special agency separate from city government that could receive state funds and eventually levy local fees to sustain the policy on its own. The state covered the first year’s $100,000 premium and set aside money for a second year.
“We implemented it. We proved we can do it,” Schaefer said. “So then the challenge is: how do you keep it going?”
A city in crisis
That challenge proved insurmountable. Around the same time the insurance pilot launched, Isleton’s city government was imploding financially — a crisis serious enough to trigger a Sacramento County Grand Jury investigation, the 10th such inquiry into city governance in 35 years.
The turmoil spilled over into the insurance district’s oversight board, which lost enough members to no longer meet quorum requirements. Today, only two people remain on the inactive board: Bulahan and former City Councilmember Iva Walton, who owns the Mei Wah Beer Room downtown.
“We’re a little small town, and what tends to happen is the same people try to help the city, and they either get burned out or they get kicked out,” Walton said. “It’s a tough place to try to make change.”
Compounding the problem, Walton said, was waning public appetite for a local tax that would have funded the policy long-term — especially once traditional flood insurance premiums dropped. “It was a hard sell for our broke-ass community,” she said.
Interim City Manager Jon Kennedy said his concerns were less about the idea itself and more about unresolved logistics, including how payouts would actually reach residents.
“It’s concerning that a program of this nature was launched without an established process for distributing potential insurance proceeds or an apparent long-term sustainability plan,” Kennedy said.
The district did purchase a one-year parametric policy that took effect in July 2025, but the board never finalized who would be eligible for a payout if a flood occurred. That policy lapsed in July and was not renewed.
Now, as rain returns to Northern California, Isleton has no backup plan in place.
“It’s so sad because it is such a great idea, and could have been such a benefit to pretty much everyone in town. And it just fell by the wayside,” Walton said. “Here we are in an El Niño year… If ever it would be nice to have extra support in case of a flood, the time would be this year.”
A statewide insurance gap
Isleton’s struggles reflect a much larger problem. More than 7 million Californians and roughly $900 billion in property sit in flood-prone areas, according to the Public Policy Institute of California. A catastrophic megaflood could cause up to $1 trillion in damage and displace 1.5 million people.
Yet statewide, only about 1.4% of households carry flood insurance, and even in federally designated high-risk zones, fewer than a third of homeowners have coverage — despite many being required to carry it under government-backed mortgages.
“We don’t like buying things we hope to never use. We don’t like thinking about disasters when it’s sunny outside,” said Carolyn Kousky, executive director of Insurance for Good. “We have a very poor understanding of risk.”
That gap is becoming more dangerous as federal disaster assistance shrinks. The Trump administration has cut FEMA staffing, withheld resilience grants and denied several recovery funding requests. Nearly two years after the devastating Los Angeles wildfires, Gov. Gavin Newsom traveled to Washington, D.C., to press Congress for $13 billion in aid that has yet to materialize.
FEMA has signaled it intends to shift more disaster response responsibility onto states, according to POLITICO reporting — even as a recent federal survey found that emergency management agencies at the state, local and tribal level are already stretched thin.
“There’s something of a perfect storm story here,” said Nicholas Pinter, associate director of the UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences. “If there is large flooding this winter, we could be on the hook for it in ways that we never would have been under previous administrations.”
A tool still worth pursuing
Despite Isleton’s setbacks, state officials argue the pilot wasn’t a failure. The Department of Water Resources says the project succeeded in drawing private insurers’ interest in developing customized, risk-based flood policies for local communities, and the agency is preparing a formal report on lessons learned.
Michael Soller, a spokesperson for the Department of Insurance, said the broader effort to expand parametric coverage remains urgent.
“It cannot happen fast enough. The challenges facing California communities from climate change are immense and require innovation at all levels,” Soller said. “No party can do this alone, and we will continue pushing for new answers to the largest problems facing local communities.”
Still, legal and logistical hurdles remain. A recent opinion from the Department of Insurance’s general counsel clarified that communities seeking parametric coverage must demonstrate insurable interest and proof of loss — requirements that have already complicated efforts by nonprofits such as Canal Alliance to secure similar policies for at-risk populations.
Other California cities have had more success. Santa Cruz purchased parametric coverage tied to earthquakes and flooding, with payouts directed to the city rather than individual residents, helping cover costs such as business interruption and damage to roads and infrastructure.
“People look to us to help them when something happens,” said Ross Brandon, the city’s risk and safety manager. “To make sure we’re up and running is probably one of the most important things.”
For Schaefer, watching Isleton’s pilot stall has been painful, but she remains hopeful that parametric insurance could still help other California communities prepare for an era of costlier, climate-driven disasters.
“I think we’re kind of collectively trying to figure it out, trying to see if it works,” she said. “Nobody is saying, ‘This is a really stupid idea.’”
Original source: CalMatters




