California Required Schools to Confirm Students Saw a Dentist — But No One Checked If They Did

Date:

A two-decade-old California law requiring incoming kindergartners to be screened for cavities and other dental problems is falling short of its goals, according to a scathing new report from the state auditor — raising concerns for families across the Inland Empire and beyond who rely on the program to catch oral health issues early.

The Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment, enacted in 2006, was designed to connect families with dentists, flag students’ dental needs and identify barriers that keep kids from getting care. But a report released November 5 by State Auditor Grant Parks found the program has been undermined by unreliable data, weak oversight and shrinking funding.

Tooth decay remains one of the most common — and most preventable — chronic illnesses among children nationwide. State data from 2021 found that 61% of California third-graders had experienced cavities during the 2018-19 school year, and experts say the problem has only worsened since the pandemic. Untreated dental issues are also linked to missed school days; a 2025 UCLA health survey found that roughly 7% of school-age children age 5 and older missed class because of dental pain.

Auditors examined six districts — Los Angeles Unified, Merced City School District, Milpitas Unified, Oakland Unified, San Luis Coastal Unified and Woodland Joint Unified — along with the California Department of Public Health, and found widespread problems with how the state tracks compliance.

None of the districts reviewed gave families complete information about the screening requirement, and none had formal procedures for following up with parents who failed to return assessment forms or who submitted waivers citing barriers to care. Five of the six districts reported numbers to the state that didn’t match their own local records.

Los Angeles Unified, the state’s largest district, mistakenly counted every first-grader toward its assessment totals for the 2024-25 school year instead of limiting the count to students who hadn’t already completed kindergarten screening in the district. The audit also found the district overstated how many students had actually turned in proof of a dental exam.

“The magnitude of the reporting errors made by L.A. Unified alone distorts any statewide analysis of the combined data,” Parks wrote in the report.

Perhaps more troubling, auditors found that no single state agency is actually responsible for overseeing the kindergarten program. Neither the California Department of Education nor the Department of Public Health monitors how well districts are complying, and the health department has never verified the data it receives or used it to track the state’s broader progress on children’s oral health. The most recent statewide data publicly available — covering the 2020-21 school year — isn’t even posted on a state website; it’s housed instead on the California Dental Association’s site.

A spokesperson for the health department, Kristine Tuzon, said state law doesn’t give the agency authority to enforce reporting requirements or notify county education offices when districts fail to submit data, pointing to existing state education code.

Local organizations that help carry out the screenings say the data problems are no surprise. Esther Yepez, associate director of wellness and oral health programs at The Los Angeles Trust for Children’s Health, said her organization spent five years coordinating school-based dental screenings for LAUSD. Even when exams were completed and forms handed over to schools, she said, campuses often failed to log the results — leaving a gap between how many students were actually screened and what the district reported to the state. It also wasn’t always clear who on campus was responsible for the paperwork.

“It was frustrating,” Yepez said, “because we had proof the screenings happened, but the schools didn’t have that information on their end.”

LAUSD did not respond to questions about the accuracy of its oral health data. In a written response included in the audit, Joel Cisneros, the district’s executive director of mental health and student wellness services, said LAUSD plans to train school staff on data entry procedures and create a standardized system for tracking returned forms and waivers.

Dental experts emphasize how much is at stake. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry recommends children see a dentist by their first birthday, yet many families face obstacles well before kindergarten. Dr. Francisco Ramos-Gómez, chair of pediatric dentistry at the UCLA School of Dentistry and director of the UCLA Center for Children’s Oral Health, said transportation issues, language barriers and a shortage of providers who accept low-income patients keep many young children from getting timely checkups.

“By the time we see some of these kids at age 3 or 4,” Ramos-Gómez said, “they already have rotten teeth, abscesses and are in serious pain.”

Funding woes are compounding the problem. The kindergarten program currently relies in part on Proposition 56 tobacco tax revenue distributed to county health departments, but auditors found that funding stream is shrinking rapidly. Starting next year, the state will no longer require counties receiving Prop. 56 dollars to use them to support the kindergarten screening program.

Tuzon said the health department is reviewing ways to sustain and strengthen compliance efforts despite the funding decline.

Eileen Espejo, senior director of health policy at the advocacy group Children Now, said the audit should prompt a broader conversation among lawmakers about the program’s future.

“Local health programs are going to have less capacity to do some of this work,” Espejo said. “There needs to be a real conversation about where the money is going to come from to help boost compliance.”

In response to the findings, Milpitas and Oakland unified school districts said they would implement the auditor’s recommendations, while Los Angeles Unified and San Luis Coastal Unified submitted partial action plans. Merced City School District and Woodland Joint Unified did not respond to the audit at all.

Original source: CalMatters

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Becerra Warns California Could Face $2 Billion Budget Shortfall if AI Bubble Bursts

California is riding high on an unexpected wave of...

Does the Democratic Supermajority Serve California Voters?

California Republicans are facing their smallest legislative footprint in...

California Mandated Dental Checkups for Students, Then Failed to Track Compliance

California's two-decade-old effort to catch dental problems in young...

Low-Quality Online Courses Could Put Students’ Financial Aid at Risk

A CalMatters investigation that revealed some California community college...