California voters have rejected Proposition 4, leaving in place a decades-old ban on using public money to help finance political campaigns for most state and local offices.
The Yes on Prop. 4 campaign conceded defeat Thursday after trailing by a narrow margin for weeks. With 99% of ballots counted statewide, the measure was failing 50.2% to 49.8%, according to the latest tally.
Had it passed, Proposition 4 would have overturned a 1988 voter-approved ban and given state and local governments the option to create public campaign financing programs. Supporters said such systems would make it easier for candidates without access to wealthy donors or personal fortunes to mount competitive campaigns.
“The razor-thin margin shows just how close California is to embracing a democracy where running for office doesn’t require personal wealth or connections to wealthy donors,” said Jenny Farrell, executive director of the League of Women Voters of California, who co-chaired the Yes campaign. She said advocates plan to bring the issue back before voters in the future.
Proposition 4 drew support from several good-government organizations and Democratic officials, who argued that publicly funded campaigns could increase electoral competition and reduce the outsized influence of major donors. They pointed to the rising cost of statewide races in recent election cycles as evidence that reform was overdue.
“We need to change the way we finance election campaigns so candidates can run and win without having to raise big money, and they can spend their time listening to voters rather than their donors,” said Trent Lange, president of the California Clean Money Campaign, who also co-chaired the measure’s campaign.
Opponents, however, said the results sent a clear message.
“The voters have been quite clear they don’t want taxpayer money being used for politics,” said Assemblymember Carl DeMaio, a San Diego Republican. “Unfortunately, politicians simply can’t take no for an answer.”
Critics of the measure raised a range of objections, from philosophical opposition to taxpayer-subsidized campaigns to concerns that the system could be exploited by candidates seeking to game public funds. Others questioned whether public financing would actually reduce the flow of private money into politics, noting that research on the issue has produced mixed results.
Mindy Romero, founder and director of the nonpartisan Center for Inclusive Democracy, said the measure’s complexity may have contributed to its close and ultimately unsuccessful outcome. While polls consistently show voters believe there is too much money in politics, she said, there is far less agreement on the right solution.
“I think people want to know what that means. Does it mean directly from my pocket? Does it mean additional taxes? Like, what does that look like?” Romero said.
Seven California charter cities — including San Francisco, Oakland and Berkeley — were exempted from the original 1988 ban and already operate public campaign financing programs. Proposition 4 would have extended that option statewide, allowing other cities, counties and the state itself to adopt similar systems voluntarily.
Under the proposal, public funds would not have been available to every candidate. To qualify, contenders would have needed to demonstrate support from a minimum number of small-dollar donors or agree to limits on how much they could raise and spend during their campaigns.
Original source: CalMatters




