As a strong El Niño pattern bears down on California this winter, water managers across the state are watching how well an old-but-newly-fashionable flood strategy performs under pressure: deliberately letting rivers spill onto the land instead of fighting to hold them back.
The approach, known as floodplain restoration, reconnects rivers with low-lying areas where high water can spread out, slow down and soak into the ground rather than pound against levees. It’s drawn significant state investment in recent years, including $40 million funneled into San Joaquin Valley floodplain projects since 2023, plus another $21.5 million set aside to jump-start similar restoration work along rivers in Kern, Kings and Tulare counties.
The concept dates back more than a hundred years. After catastrophic flooding along the Sacramento River in 1907 and 1909, state engineers concluded that levees alone wouldn’t cut it. That thinking led to construction of the Sutter and Yolo bypasses — wide floodplains designed to let the river overflow safely instead of breaching its banks.
Dos Rios State Park, which opened near Modesto in 2024, applies that same logic to the San Joaquin Valley, a region that never got a bypass system of its own. The challenge now is scale. Julie Rentner, president of the nonprofit River Partners, which led the Dos Rios restoration, estimates California needs roughly 50 more projects of similar size. With El Niño approaching and much of the $10 billion climate bond approved by voters in 2024 still unspent, there may be a window to make that happen.
Supporters argue these projects can ease downstream flood pressure and protect vulnerable communities — from Stockton and Grayson in the San Joaquin Valley to Hamilton City farther north. But Rentner says expanding the model means overcoming years of institutional habit: a tendency to pour money into patching existing flood infrastructure rather than rethinking how rivers move through the landscape.
A century-old blueprint
Six massive concrete weirs span the Sacramento River between Mount Shasta and the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, each built to divert high flows into adjacent basins or bypass channels. Some of that water eventually returns to the river. Much of it spreads across wetlands and farmland, recharging groundwater along the way.
The largest of these, the Yolo Bypass, can handle roughly four times the Sacramento River’s normal flow. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers now touts it as “a 100-year-old nature-based solution,” and researchers across the country point to it as proof that flood control, agriculture and wildlife habitat can coexist.
The state continues investing in that system. Ahead of this winter’s El Niño, Gov. Gavin Newsom marked the completion of the $31 million Tisdale Weir Rehabilitation project, an upgrade to aging flood infrastructure in Sutter County.
The San Joaquin Valley has no equivalent. A proposed expansion of the Paradise Cut Bypass could offer similar protection to flood-prone parts of Stockton, but the project has languished in the planning stages for decades.
“The magnitude of the water that needs to move through a flood bypass there in the South Delta is much, much bigger than what the Paradise Cut project can advance,” Rentner said, noting that floodplain restoration will still be necessary alongside any bypass expansion. “It’s a very good flood expansion project. We still need a couple more big bypasses like that, if Stockton’s going to be as protected as Sacramento is.”
Dos Rios as proof of concept
Lilia Lomeli-Gil remembers what flooding used to mean for her hometown of Grayson, a small farming community downstream from where the Tuolumne and San Joaquin rivers converge.
“There was a time when I was 7 or 8 years old, where we couldn’t get to Modesto because the only road that led to Modesto would get flooded,” she said.
Just upstream, on land that flooded with similar regularity, state agencies and conservation groups decided to try a different approach — welcoming the flooding instead of resisting it.
Dos Rios State Park sits about eight miles west of Modesto, at the confluence of the Tuolumne and San Joaquin rivers. The land once held two dairy operations before River Partners purchased it in 2012. According to Rentner, those farms had long struggled with chronic flood seepage and salt buildup that degraded the soil, making the land a poor long-term bet for agriculture.
River Partners now looks for similarly flood-prone parcels, working with landowners across the valley to convert struggling farmland into public floodplains.
At 2,100 acres, Dos Rios stands as the state’s largest public-private floodplain restoration effort. Gov. Newsom’s 2026-27 budget summary cites it as a signature achievement — California’s first new state park in a decade and a project that advances both flood resilience and climate goals. The state now counts it toward its broader nature-based climate targets, and advocates view it as a model for what’s possible elsewhere.
The project got an early test during the brutal winter storms of 2023. Rentner said it’s difficult to isolate the precise impact of any single floodplain within such a vast and complicated river system, but by all indications, Dos Rios performed exactly as intended — easing flood levels as far as four miles downstream without suffering infrastructure damage or significant erosion.
During that storm cycle, floodwaters spread widely across the restored acreage.
“The extent of floodplain inundation was huge,” Rentner said. “Just 10 years ago, in the 2017 high-water event, the river in this location was about a quarter mile wide in flood stage, and almost 2 feet deeper — meaning much more pressure on downstream levees.”
Obstacles to expanding the model
Rentner first came to the Central Valley roughly 25 years ago, long before Dos Rios took shape. Bringing the project to life took River Partners 14 years, from the initial land purchase to finishing final restoration work this year. She believes California needs roughly 100,000 additional acres of restored floodplain, and argues the state should shift more funding toward expanding flood-system capacity rather than simply maintaining what already exists.
Some of that funding could come from Proposition 4, the $3.8 billion bond measure voters approved in 2024 to address drought, flooding and water supply needs.
But money alone won’t solve the problem, said Jane Dolan, president of the Central Valley Flood Protection Board.
“It’s all tight budgets, huge demands,” she said. “And it takes some analysis and field work and some cooperation from property owners and civic leaders as to where to start.”
With another potentially wet winter on the horizon, attention is likely to return to the San Joaquin Valley, where communities near Stockton, Manteca and Lathrop still lack the kind of bypass protections that have long shielded the Sacramento Valley. Floodplain restoration efforts in that region remain stalled in planning, even as the need grows more urgent.
“The next step is: How do we get to implementation of the shovel-ready projects, and how do we get to the next chunk of land acquisition and restoration that we know we need to do,” Rentner said.
Original source: CalMatters




