A millennial nurse who moved from Tennessee to California said his new state is much more working-class friendly

Date:

‘I genuinely didn’t know what a break was when I moved to California’

Noah Sheidlower | Contributor

Matthew, 38, was working in northeast Tennessee as an orderly at a hospital when he realized he could live a less stressful, more lucrative life in another state doing the same work.

Matthew — whose identity is known to Business Insider and requested partial anonymity for privacy reasons — and his wife, who is also a registered nurse, decided that California would be the ideal destination. California would give him paid family leave, mandatory breaks and lunches, and better overtime laws. He said the policies of California are a lot more working-class employee friendly than in Tennessee, and since he moved in 2016, he said his work-life balance has been a lot better.

Still, he didn’t want to move to a major city like San Francisco or San Diego with a high cost of living. He settled on a city in central California which had a much lower cost of living but comparable wages for jobs.

“Many that leave California to go to the East Coast or to corporate-friendly states like Texas and Tennessee don’t know any better,” Matthew said. “They were born in California. They don’t know how good they have it.”

Matthew’s move went a little against the grain compared to how many other Americans have been switching states. The California to Tennessee move was one of the more popular routes between 2021 to 2022 at nearly 22,600 movers — though around 5,500 still made the opposite move during the same period, according to US Census data.

Many former Californians are moving to Tennessee for cheaper cost of living, friendlier people, and a slower pace of life. But for Matthew and many other former Tennesseans, California has many more opportunities for workers — and not every part of the state is outrageously expensive.

Not everything is more expensive in California

When he moved in 2016, he said his $295,000 home in California cost about as much as his Tennessee home, though housing has gotten quite a bit more expensive, he said. Though homes cost more per square foot, he said they’re also sturdier due to earthquake standards. He also said housing insurance is actually cheaper in California, and new homes are often renovated and come with new amenities, compared to homes on the market in Tennessee that aren’t as well maintained.

Additionally, he said his home in Tennessee would be frequently reassessed, which would hike up property taxes.

He said that while gas is a lot more expensive in California, he’s also driving a third of the distance to get to work or the grocery store. He also said his water bill is around three times cheaper in California.

He said he’s also willing to pay more in California for dining out as California doesn’t have a tipped minimum wage — in Tennessee, employers can pay tipped employees as little as $2.13 an hour, provided wages and tips together add up to $7.25 an hour. California has an hourly minimum wage of $15.50, which will rise to $16 in 2024.

Though the temperature gets high in central California, he said the low humidity makes summers much more bearable than Tennessee, where humidity sometimes is 100%. He hasn’t once had to scrape frost off his car as he did in Tennessee, and he doesn’t miss the tornadoes or thunderstorms that would sometimes ravage through Tennessee.

He convinced one of his friends to move out to California, though he wishes more of his family would move from Tennessee, citing better healthcare and retirement options. He said contrary to what many believe, his area of California is more laid back than in Tennessee where in his industry, people would skip lunch and fire on all cylinders to get their work done.

California is ‘more working-class friendly’

Matthew didn’t want to work as a nurse in Tennessee where nurse-to-patient ratios are low, meaning he’d have to work longer hours with few breaks and not enough pay. California requires one nurse for every two intensive or critical care patients for instance, while Tennessee does not have state laws for these ratios.

California had all sorts of policies and laws in place to protect registered nurses, including state-funded temporary disability coverage and paid baby bonding leave for up to six weeks. California also has daily overtime laws in addition to double-time pay for working over 12 hours a day, compared to weekly overtime laws in Tennessee.

Matthew was in a car accident a few years ago in California and was out on leave for 60 days for physical therapy, and he said he made the same amount he would’ve made working due to the state’s temporary disability paid for by state taxes.

“If you’re in a car accident and can’t work in Tennessee, and you didn’t take out your own individual policy from an individual insurance company that has temporary disability, you’re probably going to go bankrupt because there’s nothing to protect you.”

Additionally, he recalled how he was shocked his employers in California forced him to take a 30-minute lunch break and two other 15-minute breaks or else they would get penalized per state laws. He said one of his friends’ offices has an alarm that goes off whenever it’s time for somebody to take a break.

While the process for approving to transfer his Tennessee nursing license in California was slow, Matthew said they moved as soon as they were approved, noting how California is “everything I thought it would be as far as being employee friendly.”

His area of central California has five different hospitals, compared to just one hospital system in northeast Tennessee.

“In California, you’ve got nurses that actually get their breaks most of the time, you’ve got nurse to patient ratios, so that makes the work culture better because not everybody’s exhausted,” Matthew said. “I genuinely didn’t know what a break was when I moved to California.”

Moving to California has also made Matthew feel more economically secure about his long-term future. At his job in California, he gets a 6% 401(k) match in addition to company-funded guaranteed amount retirement pensions, compared to just 3% company matching at his job in Tennessee. He also said pay increases at his current role are a lot less arbitrary and more performance-based.

“It’s absolutely where I want to stay, unless there’s some miracle where Tennessee changes to be more employee friendly, which I don’t see ever happening,” Matthew said.

Find your latest news here at the Hemet & San Jacinto Chronicle

15 COMMENTS

  1. What a nice propaganda piece masquerading as a news article. I find it ironic no where in the “article” does it mention the high state income tax. Sales tax is similar.also no mention how without the help of COVID funds, California would be massively in debt as they have run a negative budget for the past 20 years.

  2. I’m an LPN I went to Alaska from TN. I could not believe the nurse to pt ratio was so much less had cna for 5 or 6 pt in nursing home when I told them In TN I had a floor with 52 pt on it blew their minds and the none of the nurses from other states I met carried that kind of load from 30 to 50 pt.

  3. It is surely a more worker friendly state,,,until there are no more places to work. Companies are leaving California due to some of these huge costs ($16/hour for someone to do minimum work for minimum wage).
    When and if these nurses have children they will be upset when their child goes looking for an entry level job 15 years from now to be able to learn responsibility etc. Suddenly there will be no jobs available for them any longer. Businesses did not automate in the past because it was too expensive for small business to do that—IN THE PAST!! Now, at $16/hour, 24 hours a day ,365 days a year = $140,160/ year with no vacation, breaks, insurance,sick days, workmens comp, attitude etc a $100,000 piece of equipment seems like a bargain and it will prbably last more than one year for the $100,000.

    In addition to the fear of elimination the middle class, we need to worry about the entry level joib market disappearing also.

  4. This is what I tell friends who move to Republican right to work states. Employees are more like indentured servants. Almost everyone I knew who moved to the south southeast, came back in a year

  5. I’ve been a resudent of California for over 41 years. The statement that this state is working-class friendly is the POV of most medical employees, e.g. doctors, nurses, PTs. Etc. Come to think of it, because of the continuous demand for those in the medical field.

    The grass is always greener everywhere else as long ad it’s not on one’s home ground.

    So that statement proffered by the one interviewed is his personal assessment… not a statement of fact.

  6. Gavin Newsom couldn’t have written the article better himself. Or, did he?
    Where does this guy think his money comes from, trees?

  7. California is a horrible state to live in,I lived there for 56 years and left for Tennessee 7 years ago and never looked back and I can’t even go to visit that filthy state anymore and that’s where I was born and raised but it has changed miserably in the last 15 years and is very expensive,highest taxes in the nation,highest homelessness population,litter and gangs everywhere,DMV costs is four times that of Tennessee it is also ran by a liberal lunatic in Gavin Newscum who cares less about anything except implementing terrible laws and raising taxes on everyone and everything with the exception of the mountains and Lake Tahoe and a few other places is totally not worth living there

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe to The Hemet & San Jacinto Chronicle

Popular

More like this
Related

Chicana feminist Judithe Hernández draws complex humanity at the Cheech

In a revealing video interview that accompanies her captivating 50-year survey at the Riverside Art Museum’s Cheech Marin Center for Chicano Art & Culture, artist Judithe Hernández recounts how she became the anomalous fifth member of Los Four, the groundbreaking L.A. art collective. Following the group’s ambitious 1974 exhibition at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, Hernández prevailed upon them to admit her into their ranks.

San Jacinto Valley students honored in January

The Hemet/San Jacinto Student of the Month program held its most recent recognition breakfast at the Maze Stone at Soboba Springs Golf Course on Jan. 18. Seven local high school seniors were recognized and honored for their character, love of learning and commitment to academics in addition to their involvement in school and community activities and their ability to overcome difficult life circumstances.

Soboba celebrates with sweets and hearts

Valentine’s Day brought out lots of pink and red hearts throughout the Soboba Indian Reservation as preschoolers to teenagers celebrated the extra sweet holiday on Feb. 14.

Hemet Film Festival: “Necessity Breeds Creativity”

During a sunny Saturday in Southern California, the first official Hemet Film Festival took place at the Historic Hemet Theatre on Florida Ave. On November 11th, 2023, audiences filled the red theater seats for a day spent watching movies directed by local filmmakers.